Gillian Chung’s Statement VS Edison Chen’s Attempt For Sympathy

Discussion in 'Chinese Entertainment' started by tien317, Feb 13, 2008.

  1. tien317

    tien317 Well-Known Member

    1,327
    298
    31
    Found this on Asian Fanatics forum/news and find this interesting.Credits to AF.

    Gillian Chung’s Statement VS Edison Chen’s Attempt For Sympathy

    Under EEG’s arrangement, Gillian Chung personally made a statement about the suspected nude pictures of artistes. Compared to Edison’s pre-taped statement, Gillian had more sincerity which wins her support from the entertainment ciricle!

    [​IMG] [​IMG]

    Approach

    Edison: His lawyers distributed a pre-taped video clip, 1:23 minutes in length.

    Gillian: Personally making a statement to +100 reporters. Her statement length was approximately 2 minutes long.

    Appearance

    Edison: Lame t-shirt. Didn’t really pay attention to his hair. It created a drab and dreary feeling.

    Gillian: Long straight hair which is a different hairstyle which appeared in the pictures. It was to prevent association with the pictures.

    Emotion

    Edison: Black eyes and unshaven. Unsuccessful businessman look.

    Gillina: She had makeup on and was smiling to people. She seem to be in high spirits.

    Speech

    Edison: English script. Emotionless like reading from a book.

    Gillian: Used Cantonese and emotionally expressive.

    Location

    Edison: A dimly lit room. A grey-white background which makes the location mysterious.

    Gillian: At the hotel/restaurant where her fans gathering were held. The location was bright and open. The atmosphere was warm and lively.
     
  2. mr_evolution

    mr_evolution ( • )( •ԅ(ˆ⌣ˆԅ)

    9,967
    590
    57
    Of course Gillian gets more support. Female, more fan based, clean record....
     
  3. Sweetsumigirl

    Sweetsumigirl Well-Known Member

    52
    31
    0
    Have you notice the last names between the people invovled?
    Bobo Chan Ceclia Chung
    Vincy Chan Gillian Chung
     
  4. ab289

    ab289 Well-Known Member

    3,453
    414
    283
    Shldn't it be Vincy Yeung? maybe it's the same in Chinese, but I don't know Chinese. if Yeung is the same as Chan .. then forgive me.
     
  5. hiake

    hiake Vardøgr of da E.Twin

    Not true, it's Bobo Chan and Gillian Chung, I'd give you that. But Cecilia CHEUNG with an E there, and the Vincy involved was not the new artiste from EEG (Vincy Chen) but Albert Yeung's niece Vincy Yeung...

    Chan and Cheung are common last names, even IF there's the coincidence it means nothing. Would you be surprised that more Smiths had died in the past year than Rosenbergers?
     
  6. hiake

    hiake Vardøgr of da E.Twin

    On second thought, I think this particular article missed a few important points:

    LANGUAGE:

    Gillian speaks in Cantonese because that is her native language;

    Edison speaks in English because that is HIS native language, like it or not, audiences just have to deal with the fact that Cantonese isn't the ONLY language that can delivers sincerity.

    ATMOSPHERE:

    Gillian's press conference was held IN a fan gathering, loads of support available, and if any single report dare cross the line of "upsetting Gillian", I bet he would be lynched and torn into million little pieces. Plus, EEG staged the whole thing.

    Edison's release was a lot more private, non-interactive that he stated his intent and be done with it. I almost applaud for his screw-the-world attitude.

    PUBLIC OPINION:

    Gillian is perceived as a victim, and she is given a lot of leeway in terms of her misdoings. People would have been appreciative even if she just sit there and smile.

    Edison is perceived as a criminal, the overarching rabid sentiment I have seen so far consists of certain violent death of him. No amount of good he does would likely change that particular opinion.
     
  7. negiqboyz

    negiqboyz Well-Known Member

    sympathy for neither ones .. gotta own up to their action.
     
  8. Afa

    Afa Well-Known Member

    75
    34
    0
    with masked AK wielding ppl on the background
     
  9. khaotic

    khaotic Fobulous

    This thread is pure fail.

    *Lowers head in shame*
     
  10. Giniro

    Giniro Well-Known Member

    For sure Gillian approach is much better than Edison. He look like he didnt care what happen
     
  11. Phil

    Phil 香港 PA 社團 揸Fap 人

    lol Prob Gillian is better coz shes Twins, besides most ppl blame Edison
     
  12. lazycatherine

    lazycatherine Active Member

    42
    31
    0
    i will support Gillian very much @ ....
     
  13. hiake

    hiake Vardøgr of da E.Twin

    This thread is a Gillian fan's failed attempt at objectivity -lol
     
  14. negiqboyz

    negiqboyz Well-Known Member


    yeah yeah .. you're probably another gil in reality ...lol
     
  15. keung386

    keung386 Well-Known Member

    211
    41
    0
    twins is merely a laughing stock to anyone whose not retarded in hk now
     
  16. hiake

    hiake Vardøgr of da E.Twin

    Naw, due to etiquette, people wouldn't do so much as point and laugh, but practice gossip and half smiles instead.

    And I seriously think that the majority of people consider Gillian as a victim or at least is sympathetic towards her.
     
  17. adrianc

    adrianc Well-Known Member

    everytime the names gillian, celina, edison comes up, I think of dumb coksucker, big bush (ewww), sicko pervert with std, or aids...the apology from edison was really lame, he spoke with a chinese accent...I thought he was Hk...so sad for someone that was supposed to be North American...
     
  18. xmichelly

    xmichelly Well-Known Member

    lol are you gonna say that to every thread about edison?
     
  19. khaotic

    khaotic Fobulous

    Why not. It's true :p
     
  20. xmichelly

    xmichelly Well-Known Member

    imo, it's more like .. EDISON is a failure -rolleyes