Automatic or Manual ?

Discussion in 'Science, Technology & Car Chat' started by hellohuiyang, Jan 13, 2009.

  1. Phantoman

    Phantoman Well-Known Member

    889
    270
    6
    I agree with the price issue. I think that's one of the main reasons why automatics are not so common in Europe.

    I do disagree on the fuel effeciency though. That believe stems from old automatic transmissions. See this link for fuel efficient cars and you will notice some automatics in there:
    http://www.fueleconomy.gov/FEG/bestworst.shtml

    Manuals don't neccessarily go faster either. That would depend on the engine, the driver, the type of automatic transmission, etc etc etc

    Is the Topic Starter (hellohuiyang) reading all this ? I have a feeling I am on my "automatic" bandwagon for nothing ... lol
     
  2. Phantoman

    Phantoman Well-Known Member

    889
    270
    6
    Well it all depends what you want to do with the stick :heherm: ... lol, just kidding of course.
     
  3. gordonng85

    gordonng85 Well-Known Member

    581
    68
    0
    fail-o-matic

    stick shift FTW
     
  4. Caesu

    Caesu Well-Known Member

    99
    31
    0
    =O UK has separate license for manual and auto Oo or am i reading wrong lolz
     
  5. ralliart

    ralliart Well-Known Member

    651
    68
    0
    ^^ Thats what I was wondering. lol.

    Looks like manuals more superior then auto. :D
     
  6. Phantoman

    Phantoman Well-Known Member

    889
    270
    6
    That's new to me, but then again it's also the case in the USA and some other countries.
     
  7. ^ yes they do, auto licence is for auto only, manual covers both.

    get manual, its fun and you can rev the crap out of your car, i was thinking of getting an auto cus sometimes driving manual kills your calf muscles cus of the clutch.

    auto is like mario cart
     
  8. Ragnarok043

    Ragnarok043 Well-Known Member

    45
    31
    0
    no question go for a manual. once you get the hang of it, clutching and shifting is second nature. in fact you may develop an itch for shifting. IMO manual drivers are overall better drivers too, less likely to be distracted since both hands and feet are needed to drive the car. personally driving a manual doesnt really take much more effort to drive than an automatic. even though i spend an average of 45 mins looking for parking in a hilly neighborhood, i never find myself wishing for an automatic.
     
  9. reno

    reno Well-Known Member

    f1 uses paddle shift bb :p
    u do know wat a paddle shift is rite? hahahaha

    its more like a racing simulator game!
    except it has no restart button wen u crash lol hahahaha
     
  10. hakga

    hakga Member

    12
    26
    0
    manual. more fun. more control
     
  11. Phantoman

    Phantoman Well-Known Member

    889
    270
    6
    I wonder though ... all those saying manual, did they actually try a modern automatic (e.g. not like 10 years ago) ?

    They barely sell them here in Holland, so I'm quite sure most people here wouldn't have even had the chance to drive one in their lives.

    In the USA I have the impression it's the other way around, they mostly sell automatics. Not sure if that's true, but I don't recall seeing a manual when I was over there.

    So the automatic vs manual choice might be a culture thing as well.
     
  12. Lol Automatic for me XD. I FAIL in stick shift =P
     
  13. tonkachi

    tonkachi Well-Known Member

    1,271
    86
    0
    stick is more fun to drive but i can't stand it when i'm stuck in traffic for an hour in a stick car...i'll just stick with the step-tronic transmission wher eyou get the best of both worlds minus the clutch
     
  14. sars4tw

    sars4tw Well-Known Member

    213
    41
    0
    Stick is super fun to drive...but if ur lazy like me and like to txtmsg with 1 hand n drive at the same time... auto lol
     
  15. spech

    spech Well-Known Member

    137
    41
    0
    As someone who drives only automatic, I think manual is the better choice. You have more control, save gas/the environment, and you can drive any car available to you (e.g., a friend's, a rental, etc.).
     
  16. -Tisken-

    -Tisken- Well-Known Member

    hm... never tried automatic.... i wonder how it feels like ... ? :O
    but i like manuell cuz i have the "formula 1 driver"-feeling :O
     
  17. Phantoman

    Phantoman Well-Known Member

    889
    270
    6
    lol, danger on the road! Maybe you need to use something similar to this http://www.yapme.com/.
     
  18. gordonng85

    gordonng85 Well-Known Member

    581
    68
    0
    Most fail-o-matic gearboxes are never on the right gear at the right time. Unless you go to the new Audi or Mercedes automatics, those, are beautiful.

    Another reason to stick to manual is because it is rewarding after you learned it.
     
  19. ralliart

    ralliart Well-Known Member

    651
    68
    0
    Hahaa. Fuel economy ftw!!

    Driving stick is pretty fun after you've learned it.
     
  20. fookjay07

    fookjay07 Well-Known Member

    manual for me cos changing gears seems cool;)