Source: Mingpao Translated by: KAY http://i855.photobucket.com/albums/...ntertainment/2010_OpposeAhJehFacebookPage.pngTVB's "Fun With Liza and Gods" received many applause. The show attracted 150 million viewers to watch every week. But some viewers criticized at Liza Wong (Ah Jeh)'s singing segment, pointing out her singing is terrible and it's out of tune. Netizens created a Facebook page "Strongly Request Fun With Liza and Gods' Ah Jeh Don't Sing Again" (強烈要求荃加福祿壽阿姐唔好再唱歌). More than 280,000 people have joined. They criticized she cannot handle challenging songs, out of tune and breath, plus she sings with a Cantonese opera style, they feel it's terrible to hear. The group hopes to use public pressure to pressure TVB. Besides voice of opposing, Ah Jeh has been in the showbiz for more than 40 years and already have many supporters. They support Ah Jeh saying many viewers want to see Ah Jeh perform. They praise Ah Jeh is a serious artiste that she spent lots of time in her look and outfit every episode. In addition, her performance improved lately and they hope viewers don't be too picky. Producer Ho Siu Wai thanked viewers' straight-forward opinions and knew everyone cares about the show. But the show has to cover different groups. This time is just some opinions from viewers and more than 1,500,000 people watch the show. Sometimes when they look at reactions from audience in the filming studio, the audience like Ah Jeh's performance. Ah Jeh also put effort in designing her looks and she put time in the singing segment.
I've never watched an episode of it.. plus i dont really like her in the first place. If i ever watch the show, it's because of Cho Lam or Louis. Though Cho Lam is going "down" for me.
i thought so too...lol...if the netizens think she sings too much like canto opera...then maybe they should do an opera segment then -tongue2
Most of these netizens are teenagers or early 20s. The songs that liza sang wasnt bad at all, especially the classics. HOwever, the new songs that she sang were pretty bad.....not because of her voice, but because of the songs. Newer songs sucks. Let's go 70s, 80s, and early 90s.
dont tell me you think she's good when she sang Faye Wong's "I'm Willing", or Faye's 給自己的情書, wow when she reached chorus..FAILED, those songs arent new and they're classics, esp i'm willing, 相思風雨中 is a classic too, but same problem for her...don remember the rest well but she needs to pick songs that she can actually sing oh now more than 30,000 ppl Liked the FB page XD
it's not about trying hard .. it's not about how long you have been in the industry .. sometimes, ppl gotta recognize that it's time to RETIRE.
150 million viewers watch that show every week, that is a lot. That is like, the half population of the United States.
Honestly, i really dont see anything wrong with her singing those songs. Sure, the originality wasnt there. But it's not like she's outta rythmn or tune. She just sounded so 70s. I dont think there's anything wrong wit that. Beside, i never even mention about those songs.... There were 8 episodes, she sang at least 16-20 songs. More than 80percent of it sounded good.....especially her own classic, she sounded just as good as back then. So again, there will be haters, there will be lovers.
i think everyone like the show cos of the funny parodies and her singing section is abit out of the show, like, not matching lor. she has her olden style so maybe the mature audience like but young one dun like.
