China censors "Pirates" for "vilifying Chinese"

Discussion in 'Chinese Chat' started by dim8sum, Jun 15, 2007.

  1. dim8sum

    dim8sum ♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪....

    BEIJING (Reuters) - China has censored part of the latest instalment of hit Hollywood movie "Pirates of the Caribbean" for "vilifying and defacing the Chinese", the official Xinhua news agency said on Friday.

    The role of Hong Kong star Chow Yun-Fat, who plays pirate lord Captain Sao Feng, had been slashed in half to just about 10 minutes of screen time, the report said.

    It cited local magazine The Popular Cinema as saying: "The captain played by Chow is bald, his face heavily scarred. He also has a long beard and long nails, whose image is still in line with Hollywood's old tradition of demonising the Chinese."

    "Chinese censors also cut Chow's line in which he states 'Welcome to Singapore' because it hints Singapore is a land of pirates ...," Xinhua added.

    It quoted Zhang Pimin, deputy head of the film bureau of the State Administration of Radio, Film and Television, as saying the cuts had been made "according to the country's relevant regulations on film censorship" and "China's actual conditions".

    The cuts "will not impair either the continuity of plot or the image of characters," said Zhang, declining to provide more details.

    Still, "Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End", has already performed well at the Chinese box office, Xinhua added, earning 1.18 million yuan (78,550 pounds) on its first day in Shanghai alone.

    This is not the first time a Hollywood film has angered the Chinese censor.

    Martin Scorsese's Oscar-winning "The Departed" ran into trouble due to its mention of a Chinese plan to buy military equipment, government sources told Reuters earlier this year.

    But censorship on the big screen has little impact in China, where pirated, uncut versions of the latest movies can easily be bought on the street for around $1.

    http://uk.reuters.com/article/oddlyEnoughNews/idUKPEK19683420070615?feedType=RSS
     
  2. 無得頂

    無得頂 Well-Known Member

    1,252
    86
    0
    Not surprising for China to do that. But most people download the movie anyways.
     
  3. Flames

    Flames Out of Date User

    5,149
    432
    25
    Wow I'm actually surprised at that... I thought US was the one with heavy censoring and not china, since US fully censored Dragonball Z while China/Hong Kong didn't
     
  4. dim8sum

    dim8sum ♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪....

    ^yeh all countries have their "own" censorship but china does it in a non-subtle way, if they dont like the looks of something, they will straight up censor it out

    unlike countries that may place it under the guise of national security or some bs haha
     
  5. ab289

    ab289 Well-Known Member

    3,436
    414
    271
    why censor "Welcome to Singapore"? Singapore is not in China; if Singapore government doesn't mind, funny why China would do that. China - the next world police?
     
  6. kakenx

    kakenx Well-Known Member

    398
    53
    0
    And I thought Chow Yun Fat's character was cool, but he coulda lost the long nails lol! I dont mind the scars that much.. just tells of a pirate who's fought a lot of battles.. do Singapore pirates speak canto? that's wat they were speaking in the movie, right? Well anyways going back to the censorship thing...? I guess every country has their own censor thing going on... is china trying to protect the image of neighbor Asian countries or what? "Welcome to Singapore"...
     
  7. dim8sum

    dim8sum ♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪....

    well there are chinese people in malaysia, and yeh possibly because its a neighbour, china deemed it still harmful
     
  8. nightfire117

    nightfire117 Member

    11
    26
    0
    Yes, most people download the movies. Umm, what I think is... in my post about the banning of Death Note.

    HAHA, Ab289, "China - the next world police?" Gotta love that statement. Hahaha. XDDD

    ~Nightfire
     
  9. philostrate

    philostrate Well-Known Member

    already have short screentime and yet they still censored it? pretty funny..
     
  10. pirvee

    pirvee Well-Known Member

    229
    41
    0
    pretty sensitive folk at that censor office.... nice they have ways to around these censorships ..and just download it from internet...or buy it for $ 1 at the strees -lol
     
  11. bambambob2

    bambambob2 Active Member

    40
    31
    0
    wats the point doin that singapore is not in china so china doesn't have to worry about it lol
     
  12. hiake

    hiake Vardøgr of da E.Twin

    Wow, the Chinese government surely is touchy these days... Perhaps it has something to do with the upcoming Olympics... they are probably scared to death for bad reps and rumours right now... -devil
     
  13. sean222

    sean222 Well-Known Member

    202
    41
    0
    lol that is so jokes....i think watching keira is good enough....what a good looking spunky girl
     
  14. endo

    endo Well-Known Member

    76
    31
    0
    they need to worry about the "real" pirates in China instead of movie portrayals....what a bunch of retards....
     
  15. davu4eva

    davu4eva Well-Known Member

    77
    31
    0
    US only censored Fighting scenes because they didnt want children to get ideas, and people wont feel like crap when they see a lot of blood when eating breakfast. Chinese have tight censorship on Adult content as you prob would know that recently china has blocked a lot of Adult sites from the internet access and its a crime for viewing indecent material.
     
  16. Elindra

    Elindra New Member

    2
    26
    0
    Singapore may be beside Malaysia but she is no way a neighbour of China

    I don't even know why would China care about a "Pirate" saying "Welcome to Singapore" when:
    1. Singapore is not part of China
    2. Singapore is no where near China
    3. Although there are Chinese in Singapore, they do not consider themselves PRC
    4. Singapore is a multi-racial country
    5. Why would China care when Singaporeans treat it as a joke


    Wonder if it is some PRC agenda *rolls eyes*
     
    #17 Elindra, Jun 19, 2007
    Last edited: Jun 19, 2007
  17. singlung2099

    singlung2099 Well-Known Member

    258
    53
    0
    China's cencorship is political in nature
     
  18. ChilliChidori

    ChilliChidori Well-Known Member

    345
    53
    0
    They censored just banal stuff. I think nobody cares about long nails, scars or the "Welcome to Singapore" at all.
     
  19. dukane

    dukane New Member

    3
    26
    0
    Time to time the censors have to show some efficiency so why not to do it in this movie where nobody can complain about it. Better cut few images then half of the story.