Has Chinese New Years lost it's edge?

Discussion in 'Chinese Chat' started by drsnoopy, Feb 21, 2007.

  1. drsnoopy

    drsnoopy Well-Known Member

    634
    68
    0
    Is it me? Or has CNY lost it's meaning, and really lost all tradition. I was reading something online, and it said that traditionally people would write on paper with a "mo but" and y'know write "fai chun" to put on their doors, or things with actual meaning. Now? It's freaking printed.

    Is tradition still big in your household?
    Would you still plan to keep it alive for the next generation?
    If I asked you right now? What CNY was all about, would you know? Could you answer?
     
  2. ahhbailey

    ahhbailey Member

    17
    26
    0
    its just printed so it looks nicer
     
  3. smallrinilady

    smallrinilady Well-Known Member

    totally, with printed
    you can get it with lots of different colours and embossed with gold foil and whatnot
     
  4. Knoctur_nal

    Knoctur_nal |Force 10 from Navarone|

    16,563
    662
    29
    hell, i think the tradition is still strong...but not what it used to be on the old days for sure.
     
  5. aimee4ever

    aimee4ever Active Member

    34
    31
    0
    Whoa, I didn't know that people print it now. At home, my family still celebrate CNY traditionally. ^^
     
  6. ab289

    ab289 Well-Known Member

    3,436
    414
    271
    well, the printed materials are ... an improved version of CNY? That does not mean it has lost it's meaning or tradition. Tradition is still the things you still do during CNY; like decorations (printed or written), clean house, reunion dinners, etc.
     
  7. dim8sum

    dim8sum ♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪....

    of course as with all traditions they get diluted. So CNY becomes more like western new year for many young people, but the older generation are there to remind us of tradition
     
  8. hiake

    hiake Vardøgr of da E.Twin

    I know to a certain extent what Chinese New Year means, afterall I learned it in primary school back in Hong Kong.
    But for the hanging-writing thing, I sincerely think it's a shame to display my horrible chinese calligraphy, otherwise I would write it myself in ink. Serious. Plus, not many practice ink calligraphy nowadays -- that's why the printed ones are so popular -- since everyone got horrible looking handwriting!
    But I do agree that the tradition has slowly gave way to "a day to collect red pocket" instead of a day to celebrate.
     
  9. tdmt

    tdmt Well-Known Member

    236
    41
    0
    ab289 is right. there are many things people still do to keep the traditions alive
     
  10. carmenq

    carmenq Member

    21
    26
    0
    It has lost its touch this year, just because I think it's starting to become another Christmas with all the items on sale in American stores. Though they are printed, that doesn't really matter, but I don't feel the hype like I used to.
     
  11. Keepin' in touch wit the Asians my brother -coolio

    another sad thing i read.. hella pple dinning out now... I'll try to find article later.. but pple aint even eatin at homes.. in China as a matter of fact..
     
  12. jnetcube5

    jnetcube5 Well-Known Member

    413
    53
    0
    i'll have to say for my family Chinese New Years isn't as traditional anymore.
     
  13. tdmt

    tdmt Well-Known Member

    236
    41
    0
    well, even if it's not as traditional like before, i feel like still looking forward to every new year holiday
     
  14. chi-bi-rain

    chi-bi-rain Active Member

    38
    31
    0
    its getting more and more commercialized liek everyhting else
     
  15. duckie21

    duckie21 Member

    14
    26
    0
    CNY might have lost some of it's excitement but it's always good to receive the red envelopes...
     
  16. haobuhao

    haobuhao Well-Known Member

    99
    31
    0
    its more commercial, but we still follow the tradition and meaning
     
  17. YoungPeezy

    YoungPeezy Member

    5
    26
    0
    ya wut he pplz said here
     
  18. razorw

    razorw Well-Known Member

    88
    31
    0
    Traditions evolve and grow. Its rules are flexible with interpretation and change. One needs to be flexible to survive.
     
  19. AoiSora

    AoiSora Member

    5
    26
    0
    Seeing as my almost all 28 of my cousins and their parents are in HK and I'm in Canada, it's hard for me to go over during CNY, especially since I'm in school. Too bad we don't get CNY off, cuz my parents told me in HK they got like 2 weeks off during CNY for the eithre traditional procedure, what w/ the food, veggie meal, eat leftovers from first day, etc.
     
  20. lee337x

    lee337x Member

    13
    26
    0
    Today all we care about is work not family any more... and also we are getting more westenize.. we are losing our culture..