Review: Palm's small, cheap Centro

hiake · Oct 17, 2007

Review: Palm's small, cheap Centro

NEW YORK (AP) -- Here's one thing I can say for certain about the new Palm Centro smart phone: it comes with a Sudoku game.

For nearly a week, that was the only thing I could say about the Centro, because I spent most of my time with the phone playing that very addictive game.

Then, through a supreme act of will, I eventually tore myself away. Well, to be perfectly honest, I got stuck on the "Diabolical" difficulty level and gave up. That allowed me to notice that the phone itself isn't half bad.

Palm Inc.'s flagship smart phone is the Treo, which has been pretty popular since it was introduced in 2002. But recently, competitors have edged in on its niche. The BlackBerry is now available in models that don't immediately make you look like a corporate e-mail slave. Apple Inc.'s iPhone has made a splash with an interface so beautiful it makes you feel like you're holding a still pond in your hand.

The Centro is Palm's way of fighting back, by making a Treo that's smaller, cuter and cheaper. It's just $99 with a two-year Sprint contract (after a mail-in rebate), making it probably the cheapest smart phone yet. It would have been more interesting if Palm fought back by revamping its outdated software, but if small and cheap are on sale, I'll take it.

Remarkably, the Centro makes few compromises despite the smaller size - there's about a third of an inch less of it in every dimension compared with the Treo 700p, from last year. There's no external antenna, making it very pocketable. Its corners are nice and rounded.

The Centro's full-alphabet keyboard is tiny, but the keys are soft and raised high, making them easy to press with the nails. Nail-biters, however, are going to have a problem typing.

Talk time is decent, despite a smaller battery. I measured it at 4 hours at maximum signal strength, beating the manufacturer's figure of "up to 3.5 hours."

The screen is small, at 2.2 inches diagonally, but very sharp, with the same 320-by-320-pixel resolution as the best of the Treos. That's good for Sudoku.

The only real hardware problem is the memory-card slot. It's partly obscured by the battery cover, making it very tough to insert and remove the card by the procedure recommended in the manual. Once I figured out that it's best to remove the battery cover to access the slot, things went better, but this added step shouldn't be necessary.

There's also the issue of the stylus. The iPhone is designed to be operated with the fingers alone, and makes the stylus seem so '90s. Regular Treos can be used quite well with the fingers alone, but the Centro's smaller screen makes the stylus more essential. Unfortunately, the Centro's stylus is a chintzy plastic thing, not metal like the Treo's, and it's easy to lose.

Treos are available either with Microsoft Corp.'s Windows Mobile operating system, or Palm OS. Neither gets a lot of love from consumers. I've used the Palm software for quite a while, and I prefer it over Windows because it's easier to use, so I think Palm made a good choice in putting that on the Centro too. But a lot of people report being driven crazy by unreliable Palm OS Treos, so I just may have been lucky.

Apart from ease of use, the other strong side of the Palm system is that there are thousands of applications that will run on it. The integration with the phone functions, and with Microsoft Outlook on the computer side, is well executed as well.

The included e-mail application is designed to work with Microsoft's Exchange corporate server and popular Web e-mail services like Gmail. The Web browser is decent, and the Centro's touch screen makes it much more useable than on non-touch smart phones, because you can tap links easily. It rides on Sprint Nextel Corp.'s third-generation broadband network, which makes for speedy browsing and downloads.

Palm's weakest spot is in entertainment. Videos are very small on the screen. The included music-player software wastes precious screen real-estate and is clumsy to navigate. Along with the problematic card slot, which you'll need to use if you plan to carry around more than about 10 songs, this makes it tough to recommend the Centro as a music player.

Overall, I can imagine worse uses for $99 than buying a Centro, particularly for someone who hasn't had a smart phone before. The ability to do e-mail, browse the Web and synchronize calendars and contacts with Microsoft Outlook will certainly be appreciated. A model with black finish went on sale Sunday. For one in lipstick red, you have to wait until Nov. 4.

Don't fixate too much on the low price, however. Remember that the initial cost of a smart phone is dwarfed by the cost of service over the two-year contract run. The $100 mail-in rebate is only available if you sign up for a data plan that costs at least $25 a month, in addition to a voice plan. That puts the minimum monthly fee at $60 a month for voice and data, or with taxes and fees, closer to $70. That's $1,680 over two years.

In that context, plunking down another $300 initially to get an iPhone instead doesn't seem so steep. It blows the Centro away when it comes to media functions and Web browsing.

But did I mention the Centro does Sudoku?

Source: http://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/stories/T/TECH_TEST_PALM_CENTRO?SITE=ININS&SECTION=TECHNOLOGY&TEMPLATE=DEFAULT&CTIME=2007-10-17-15-49-15
Click to expand...

While I know that many of us don't belong to the target market of the Palm series, I just found Sudoku as the punchline to be EXTREMELY funny.

ah_wong201 · Oct 17, 2007

hahahh i wonder how many ppl will buy the phone for the sudoku.

hiake · Oct 17, 2007

I am sure I personally will save and invest that $1,680+ and buy a play sudoku online -tongue2

Knoctur_nal · Oct 17, 2007

This thing seems to be a hit.
Telus Canada just came out with the HTC Windows Mobile version/

xmichelly · Oct 18, 2007

looks nice, but I wouldn't buy it for sudoku lol
I've never played sudoku before -blush

runtohell121 · Oct 18, 2007

lol is that phone for sprint? if so its not gsm

hiake · Oct 18, 2007

xmichelly said: ↑

looks nice, but I wouldn't buy it for sudoku lol
I've never played sudoku before -blush
Click to expand...

The "fait accompli" feeling of finishing a Sudoku while others struggle on is not unlike you secretly KNOW that you are smarter than the rest of the crowd, proven via Sudoku -tongue2

xmichelly · Oct 18, 2007

hiake said: ↑

The "fait accompli" feeling of finishing a Sudoku while others struggle on is not unlike you secretly KNOW that you are smarter than the rest of the crowd, proven via Sudoku -tongue2
Click to expand...

I don't do sudoku because I don't want people to feel inferior

hiake · Oct 18, 2007

xmichelly said: ↑

I don't do sudoku because I don't want people to feel inferior
Click to expand...

Problem being, they usually are [inferior].

-tongue2

J/K

Review: Palm's small, cheap Centro

hiake Vardøgr of da E.Twin

ah_wong201 Well-Known Member

hiake Vardøgr of da E.Twin

Knoctur_nal |Force 10 from Navarone|

xmichelly Well-Known Member

runtohell121 ........................

hiake Vardøgr of da E.Twin

xmichelly Well-Known Member

hiake Vardøgr of da E.Twin