Woman sues after 'winning' $500,000 scratch-off ticket is called misprint

Discussion in 'The Lounge' started by AC0110, Jun 7, 2010.

  1. AC0110

    AC0110 Let the Fun Begin

    3,913
    377
    52
    An Ocala woman wants a jury to decide if the Florida Lottery was wrong to dismiss her winning ticket as a misprint.

    [​IMG]

    Ann Marie Curcio claims the Lottery is in breach of its contract with buyers because it will not pay $500,000 she says she is owed for her winning Gold Rush ticket.

    "We don't believe that there is a sufficient excuse for the Lottery not to pay it. . . . There are no disclaimers on the ticket," said Larry Walters, Curcio's Orlando-based attorney.

    Curcio bought her $20 ticket on May 13, 2007. The winning numbers 28, 1, 12, 32 and 2 appeared on the ticket.

    She scratched her ticket to find the number 1, which matched the one of the five winning numbers and had $500,000 printed beneath it as the payout.

    When Curcio tried to redeem her ticket at the Florida Lottery's Tallahassee offices the following day, she was told that the ticket was misprinted.

    Lottery officials say they need to inspect Curcio's ticket to determine whether it is a winning ticket — and that Curcio has not filed a winner's claim form.

    "We're sympathetic and empathetic to a player who may feel like they won, but they haven't followed the appropriate protocol," Lottery spokeswoman Jacqueline Barreiros said. "We're not in the business of withholding anything from anyone, but we do have to safeguard the integrity of the game."

    Walters said Curcio's ticket was dismissed right away as a misprint, so there was "no point in submitting a form" but that Curcio would be glad to complete one if it meant that the agency would pay her ticket.

    The Lottery website reports buyers have a 1-in-2.95 chance of winning at least $20 with a Gold Rush ticket, and a 1-in-2.5-million chance of winning $500,000.

    It's not clear how many times people with tickets that are apparent winners have been told that the tickets were misprints.

    "We've heard of at least a few other instances of winning tickets that were presented and the Lottery claimed they were misprinted and refused to pay," said Walters.

    It's also possible that if a winning ticket could be a misprint, so could a losing one, Walters said.

    "We know that if it happens one way, it happens the other way as well," he said.

    Curcio also is seeking more than $15,000 in damages, the statutory minimum for a civil suit in circuit court. The suit was filed Wednesday in Leon County.

    Source
     
  2. bullocks! she should sue for $500,000
     
  3. AC0110

    AC0110 Let the Fun Begin

    3,913
    377
    52
    ^
    I agree, she's pretty dumb for suing merely for $15,000...

    I would go ask $500,000 and then have an agreement to meet half way, which would be $250,000... and this would be worst case scenario...

    Because I don't see how the woman would lose the lawsuit... it's almost like fraud or scam
     
  4. EvilTofu

    EvilTofu 吃|✿|0(。◕‿◕。)0|✿|吃

    6,283
    497
    449
    I hope she didn't buy anything expensive before she went and found out it's a misprint.
     
  5. i don't see how she's dumb... there is not enough damage to warrant $500,000 in reimbursements. And if there is not enough damage to warrant $500,000, then she will get $0 back. $15,000 sounds more likely, and she has more chance of winning a lawsuit by suing for $15,000 than $500,000.

    Now if luck is on her side, she gets $500,000 of the lost ticket prize + $15,000.

    Sounds pretty smart to me.
     
  6. lovetvb

    lovetvb Well-Known Member

    370
    53
    0
    Misprint and still for sale? Are you kidding me? She already paid for it...it's like a contract there...If it is wrongly print, they should recall it right away...not waiting for someone with the " winning" ticket to show up and say " hahaha...you got punk !!" That's f...king no way Don't act like a dumbass...C'mon ,wtf...Lottery is a business, it's not a child game... If it is me, I will sue for $500,000 or nothing...better chance than winning a ticket...
     
  7. ericlala

    ericlala Active Member

    25
    26
    0
    lawyer dude is right, if that was a misprint, it could mean any of the losing tickets is a misprint too
     
  8. Giniro

    Giniro Well-Known Member

    She should claim the 500,000 and the sued another 100,000 for damages