Do you consider yourself Chinese, if you werent born in China but your parents were?

Discussion in 'Chinese Chat' started by dim8sum, Apr 28, 2006.

?

Do you consider yourself (or someone) Chinese?

  1. Yes

    309 vote(s)
    95.4%
  2. No

    15 vote(s)
    4.6%
  1. don

    don ello

    my parents are born in hk and im also was born there......i moved to canada at like the age of 1 but i still consider myself chinese
     
  2. tbtang81

    tbtang81 Member

    17
    226
    0
    Yes, I consider myself to be Chinese. I was born in Vietnam, but my dad was born in China and my mom's parents were born in China also.
     
  3. kdotc

    kdotc 안녕하세요빅뱅K-Dragon입니다

    ^ so u speake viet and chinese?
     
  4. camme86

    camme86 Member

    16
    26
    0
    Re: Do you consider yourself Chinese, if you werent born in China but your parents we

    I consider myself as Chinese. The black hair shows it too (I live in Europe).
     
  5. kimmimuichi

    kimmimuichi Member

    15
    26
    0
    I'm a proud CHINESE canadian
     
  6. angelic_soul

    angelic_soul Active Member

    25
    26
    0
    Of course I'm chinese! My parents were born in Hong kong, but I was born in the US..still, I'm 100% Chinese
     
  7. hkm91450

    hkm91450 Well-Known Member

    I consider myself 100% Chinese and am damn proud to be Chinese :)
     
  8. dim8sum

    dim8sum ♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪....

    ^ Dam right! -rockon!
     
  9. winterfuyu

    winterfuyu Well-Known Member

    76
    31
    0
    uhm, say your ethnicity is 100% chinese
    but you were born in africa.
    you don't speak/read/write chinese,
    but you look chinese.

    are you african or chinese? :/
    there's an obvious answer (if you think the other way you're insane -_-), but i guess overall it depends on how you think.
     
  10. hkm91450

    hkm91450 Well-Known Member

    ^ Do you mean you personally? I think it's a personal choice of course.
    But I know some people whose parents are from Hong Kong, but were missionairies or had jobs with the government, and so they had to live in South America or Africa, and therefore their kids were born there. But they still consider themselves 100% Chinese.

    I think in the end, it depends how much that person values themselves as Chinese. I know lots of people who deny the fact that they are Chinese because they are born in a country like Canada or the US. Lots of overseas Chinese don't see the significance of their ethnic culture.
     
  11. aussiekid

    aussiekid Well-Known Member

    174
    41
    0
    er "CHINESE" isn't onli meant for ppl born in CHINA .. why so many idiots alwayz get this wrong.. esp those angmohs in aus also.. juz bcoz i'm from malaysia, they thot i'm malay.. walao..
    my granparents from china.. and i'm CHINESE.. MALAYSIAN CHINESE.. pissing me off.. can't stand idiots thinkin "chinese" is for CHINA onli..
     
  12. kdotc

    kdotc 안녕하세요빅뱅K-Dragon입니다

    if ur family speaks chiens and u speak chinese then u're chinese
     
  13. Klutzy

    Klutzy Member

    13
    226
    0
    yeah - its completely irrelevant where you were born.
     
  14. ms-jojo

    ms-jojo Well-Known Member

    834
    68
    0
    i was born in Canada and have only been to China twice in my life. i still consider myself Chinese because i communicate with my relatives in Chinese and go to Chinese school.
     
  15. ms-jojo

    ms-jojo Well-Known Member

    834
    68
    0
    whoa.. i think dim8sum just put "born in China" for simplicity. you don't expect someone to say "born in any country that has people speaking Chinese", do you?

    i mean, i understand how you feel. people constantly assume my family's from HK just because we speak Cantonese, and not Guangzhou (which can really piss me off sometimes), but just chill...
     
  16. ribsandbbqbeef

    ribsandbbqbeef Well-Known Member

    707
    271
    0
    I consider myself an American Born Chinese, not fully Chinese, not fully American. I believe that to identify oneself with a certain ethnicity, one is typical of that culture, their practices, and their beliefs.

    For me, I have traits of being Chinese when it comes to academics, work ethics, taste in food, taste in entertainment. However I also have American traits when it comes to dating, relationship with women, career advancemnt, ideas about how to have fun, and how to dress.

    So to say I'm Chinese is not completely right, but to say I'm American is also incorrect. I am an American Chinese, with the best traits from both cultures all mixed in one! Yeah!
     
  17. brown_bear

    brown_bear ☆‧° ☆﹒﹒‧ ☆ ﹒﹒‧☆‧° ☆

    8,870
    467
    21
    i totally think that im chinese even though i was born in UK as my parents were born in china and its your heritage (i think) anyway your parents background which is your background
     
  18. dim8sum

    dim8sum ♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪....

    Thanks ms-jojo you know where im coming from.

    But yeh aussiekid, you raise a valid point (but no need to go off on one...), so why not discuss it further.

    So I guess at what point is someone considered chinese? Are they chinese as long as one of their ancestors has chinese blood? As long as they speak chineses (but some white people can speak mandarin fluently, so are they chinese?

    I guess as long as you have chinese blood, i would say your chinese. Anyways the purpose of this thread was not to say who is chinese and who is not, but to hear what people personally believe they are.
     
  19. ribsandbbqbeef

    ribsandbbqbeef Well-Known Member

    707
    271
    0
    By your definition then, if a person has one grandparent who is Chinese, the other 3 Japanese, and his own parents are Japanese as well; he was born & raised in Japan. Could he call himself Chinese, since by definition he has 1/4 Chinese blood in him? That would be a hard pressed claim...