Do you ever have trouble listening to canto music?

Discussion in 'Chinese Chat' started by uryu, Jun 1, 2006.

  1. sobe

    sobe Member

    6
    26
    0
    I listen to canto songs mostly, but can't understand the whole song. Maybe just bits and pieces of it... haha.
     
  2. zita3000

    zita3000 Active Member

    41
    231
    0
    i know cantonese. ^^
    but my pronouciation is not exactly all that great (since i had english influence ever since i was a kid)
     
  3. cothfy

    cothfy Active Member

    28
    226
    0
    I enjoy listening to cantonese music, but find it very hard to understand lyrics with deep meanings.
     
  4. vexhawk

    vexhawk New Member

    2
    26
    0
    If you know how to translate Mandarin into Cantonese it becomes helpful in understanding Cantonese music. If you know Classical Chinese it's even better. Cantonese music is sang in poetic form. Learning to read the news paper (which is sometimes written very formally) will also help.

    I use to have so much trouble understanding Cantonese music even though I am fluent. It wasn't until I took a course on Classical Chinese (文言文) that I understood the songs fully.

    I know that a lot of us would rather Cantonese songs be conversation like; but I think its very poetic that they still sing in that way; it adds so much more meaning to all of the songs.
     
  5. auta

    auta Well-Known Member

    298
    53
    0
    i remmeber the first time i actually started listening to canto music (i was into white music for like the first 14 years of my life) i was having difficulty ujst understanding what there on about. but as time goes past and you listen to more and more you start to pickup the songs both lyrical wise and understand what there talking about. nowdays i can sing along and understand =D
     
  6. Chibi12

    Chibi12 Well-Known Member

    yep, i always have this problem, i never seem to fully understand wat they hell they're saying, but then again, i have the same problem with the news too!
     
  7. KaMaN^^v

    KaMaN^^v Member

    16
    26
    0
    depends on the accent
     
  8. spikeeleon

    spikeeleon New Member

    2
    26
    0
    never did fully understand cantonese ><
    i can however fully understand mandarin :D
     
  9. 8570

    8570 Member

    19
    26
    0
    i never understand the fully meaning of the songs, mostly just pieces of them >.<
     
  10. kenryuakuma

    kenryuakuma Active Member

    35
    231
    0
    Well...Mandarin music is my fav. Cantonese music or song is ok to me. But I hardly really listen to them as they are no better than rap music. I guess because of the melody or whatever. I am not really that interested in Cantonese music. What I am listening is En, Man as well as Jap or sometimes Ko.....Very least often I will listen to Cantonese music.
     
  11. Myer

    Myer Well-Known Member

    72
    234
    0
    Well, I understand NOTHING because sung Cantonese is pretty sophisticated Cantonese, in my opinion... ^^
     
  12. person

    person Well-Known Member

    Yeah, I usually have trouble listening to the songs.
    I just end up humming to the music.
     
  13. tricky7_

    tricky7_ Well-Known Member

    99
    31
    0
    The reason why it's hard for us to understand canto music lyrics is because they sing in a more formel cantonese.
    For example they use 不 [bat] instead of 唔 [mh] for "no/not" , they use 他 [taa] instead of 佢 [kuih] for he/her.
     
  14. ralphrepo

    ralphrepo Well-Known Member

    5,274
    459
    249
    Its the same as written Chinese. If you know how to read and write in Chinese then its not a problem. People who are functionally illiterate (that is, can only speak Chinese) won't be able to decipher the written forms of the language as easily.

    Ralph
     
  15. polar43

    polar43 Member

    6
    26
    0
    Sometimes, its probably due to not understanding some of the formalities used. I guess having the lyrics handy helps ^^
     
  16. dawgxmaster

    dawgxmaster Well-Known Member

    55
    31
    0
    i only understand the basic canto
     
  17. namelessl3oy

    namelessl3oy Member

    19
    26
    0
    haha same problem too :D
     
  18. ProjectD

    ProjectD VIP yay :]

    yeah same thing happens to me but theres always lyrics to look forward too
    so i guess its okay
     
  19. schung23

    schung23 Well-Known Member

    64
    31
    0
    haha yes : )
     
  20. azndude18

    azndude18 Active Member

    29
    26
    0
    i think canto music is harder to understand because it is more formal rather than day-to-day conversational canto we are use to hearing and speaking.