Does Evil exists?

Discussion in 'Philosophy & Religion' started by wind2000, Sep 16, 2007.

  1. AC0110

    AC0110 Let the Fun Begin

    3,913
    377
    52
    Then you can go have yourself get eaten and you can tell me after...
     
  2. ih8nayms

    ih8nayms Member

    14
    26
    0
    How can evil exist when it is a mere concept?
     
  3. KilaKilaGirl

    KilaKilaGirl Well-Known Member

    2,207
    493
    1,832
    People say that "evil exists only in the eyes of the beholders
     
  4. AC0110

    AC0110 Let the Fun Begin

    3,913
    377
    52
    If you say that's a mere concept then wouldn't everything else we created a concept then?
     
  5. wysandman

    wysandman Well-Known Member

    609
    268
    0
    I don't even know what you mean by that.
    Why don't you tell what you think if evil exist or not.
     
  6. tg79

    tg79 Active Member

    31
    31
    0
    Yes, evil does exixst but end of the day it depends on how strong a person can control the evilness in their heart and the type of environment the person grew up in.
     
  7. I'm going to take a very relative point of view on this. Yes, evil exists, but not in an independent and strictly set sense.

    Although it's tempting (and to some extent carved into human nature), evil should not be defined as one thing or another. Doing so only gives rise to moral dilemmas and forces a need for an utilitarian approach to life. We can't say that murder is evil, for claiming so gives birth to the moral dilemma of killing a hundred to save a thousand. We cannot say theft is evil, for that gives rise to the moral dilemma of whether or not to steal a scientist's Death Star plans to save millions. Alternately we cannot claim lying is bad, for it gives rise to the moral dilemma of whether or not one should lie to a friend about his cancer to keep him happy enough so that he would not commit suicide.

    I suggest reading Nietzsche for a better explanation of some depth, in particular section 201 where he claims that

    So as a quick wrap-up, evil can to some extent exist, but not as a set rule of black-and-white divisions and definitions, but rather what society needs and does not need to develop and progress as a whole which is forever ephemeral and changing.
     
  8. matethemouse

    matethemouse Well-Known Member

    237
    41
    0
    reminds me of the greek story "Ring of Gyges".
     
  9. AC0110

    AC0110 Let the Fun Begin

    3,913
    377
    52
    ^
    But that's more about a just man and an unjust man...

    I just finish reading that book before the holiday..
    Plato: Republic ^^
     
  10. gawain187

    gawain187 Well-Known Member

    I think evil DOES exist. Because if you think about it,

    If there was no Evil then there will be NO WAR! No racism, No poor people
     
  11. darkstryker

    darkstryker Member

    11
    26
    0
    There's always evil, when there's light there's a shadow
     
  12. matethemouse

    matethemouse Well-Known Member

    237
    41
    0
    but you can have only light space (thinking of the Big Bang explosion) and only dark space (thinking of the "dark matter" stuff)