Heart of greed vs Heart of greed 2

Discussion in 'Heart of Greed II - 溏心風暴之家好月圓' started by demoniac, Sep 27, 2008.

  1. sunnydaiz

    sunnydaiz Well-Known Member

    58
    31
    0
    It's hard to say, I think both are interesting in their own ways. Here's hoping there's a 3rd season.
     
  2. serebii

    serebii Well-Known Member

    125
    243
    1
    definitely heart of greed 2, i love the storyline of it. it makes me feel so angry omg. really
     
  3. devilz333

    devilz333 Member

    17
    26
    0
    i like the second one, it's jus that it was too long!
     
  4. tangoone1

    tangoone1 Member

    15
    26
    0
    anyone still have the ep for dl ?
     
  5. mrsus

    mrsus Member

    21
    226
    0
    MR was a lot better than HOG! The plot didn't drag on as much, and Michelle Yim in MR was a much better "evil" person than Susanna Kwan was in HOG... I found that the drama in HOG was annoying and pissed the hell out of me... MR portrayed the evil-ness much better!
     
  6. e5liu

    e5liu Member

    14
    26
    0
    i watched the 2nd one before i watched the first one, and i felt like the first one was missing the wholeness factor.. nothing like the awesome family spirit in the 2nd
     
  7. rakushin

    rakushin Member

    13
    26
    0
    hog2 is better~~
     
  8. rockroll

    rockroll New Member

    0
    25
    0
    the second one 'Moonlight Resonance' is much more better.. not only of the plot is more interesting, even the love part of the series is more touching than then first one plus all the background songs... lastly the ending of MR is more realistic compared to HOG that both of them got married even they haven start dating before !!! that's complete lame for sure...
     
  9. oneandonlytiffy

    oneandonlytiffy New Member

    4
    26
    0
    in HOG, the love storyline was good and the family drama was cliché; but in MR, the love storyline was cliché, and the family drama was good! if only tvb had switched it around!
     
  10. blueaura18

    blueaura18 Active Member

    32
    231
    0
    i think the 2nd one is just slightly better. it take a little longer to get going but overall its more touching and has a nicer ending for me.
     
  11. Jetez

    Jetez Active Member

    33
    31
    0
    i think hog is much more funny and less dramatic and moses was the main character and MR is good too everyone was very into their characters but in every episode u can expect yelling and screeming
     
  12. rNb99

    rNb99 Well-Known Member

    856
    268
    0
    i like moonlight resonance way way more. heart of greed gets boring at some stage
     
  13. mcescher

    mcescher Member

    10
    26
    0
    Agree. It took me a few weeks to finish HOG 1 thinking I needed to see that first before HOG 2. Finished HOG 2 in less than 2 weeks because it was so good. Realize didn't even need to watch HOG1.
     
  14. machete

    machete New Member

    3
    26
    0
    heart of greed 2 is better
     
  15. SweetCookies74

    SweetCookies74 Well-Known Member

    50
    31
    0
    Moonlight resonance FTW.
    but I hate kate. she's annoying.
     
  16. Physica

    Physica Well-Known Member

    389
    53
    0
    first one by far.
    Because when i was watching the second one, it was like the same idea also they have similiar ending as the first one.
    The idea of the second one is just not as fresh as the first one did.

    o btw what was the actors name of the youngest brother that was in"manchester" HE CAN'T ACT... sorry but that was also a huge -point
    what also irritated me was the daughter that couldn't speak
    Also what does the people/directors of tvb have lately... all those disabled people in all these serie's not that i don't like them.
     
  17. mochi21

    mochi21 Member

    13
    26
    0
    'Moonlight' is so much better than the first. I so did not want to watch the 'Moonlight' because I thought 'Heart' was so bad that I cursed myself in renting it and wasting money. 'Moonlight' is much better despite of chessy scenes and predictable events it was still a much watchable sequel to the first. I think Moses even liked his character here more than 'Dak Dak Day' as he seem to act more natural.
     
  18. DDdrama

    DDdrama Member

    22
    26
    0
    The first one is better than the second one!!
     
  19. DDdrama

    DDdrama Member

    22
    26
    0
    The first one is better than the second one!!
     
  20. or3olov3r

    or3olov3r Member

    10
    26
    0
    HOG 2 mainly because of Raymond didn't die and was one of the main character