Smooth and tanned is cool but I'm not hating on any color. Also, I didn't think smooth skin mattered much till I met this one girl awhile ago and lets just say my friends called her dinosaur cause her skin was all bumpy and stuff. I couldn't do nothing with it. Just like I couldn't stay on the phone with a girl that sounds like a guy. Turn off.
It doesn't matter if it's tanned or white, but i would prefer smooth skin cause it usually means the person takes care of themselves. and psychologically it makes me feel that they're youthful and beautiful.