Suicides?

Discussion in 'Philosophy & Religion' started by dwild, Feb 19, 2006.

  1. AC0110

    AC0110 Let the Fun Begin

    3,913
    377
    52
    Well, not everything have to come out of the Bible and has to be true.

    Unless you have full knowledge knowing what you are doing exactly and kill yourself than I think it's a sin
    However, if you are having a very emotional time creating metal illness and that person commit sucide. Would you count that as a sin? I think not
     
    #21 AC0110, Jul 4, 2006
    Last edited: Jul 4, 2006
  2. lil_azn_kev

    lil_azn_kev Member

    13
    26
    0
    Suicides cause ur a vegetable nothign wrong with but how can u decide if ur a vegetable. ?
    killing ur self cuase ur lover dumped u- no brain
    klling ur self cause ur broke.. -stupid/ weak

    suicde to save lifes or to do somethign great- priceless (die with honor not with sorrow)
     
  3. don

    don ello

    there are so many reasons why a person would suicide
     
  4. kdotc

    kdotc 안녕하세요빅뱅K-Dragon입니다

    anythign can cause a person to suicide
     
  5. Tao_lung

    Tao_lung Well-Known Member

    107
    41
    0
    Agreed, people who commit suicide are all cowards. ITs just a darn scape goat in life. To live and facing your problems is what any person should do. A life is but a life. Sin or not one should always live, everything has a reason, just need to see it at the end. To live is to learn, to learn is to become better, to be better is becoming wiser. Though that may have more then one interpratation, live the life you want to and be happy with it.
     
  6. don

    don ello

    you really won't know how a person wanting to suicide feels
     
  7. Tao_lung

    Tao_lung Well-Known Member

    107
    41
    0
    well wouldn't one have given up all hope and doesn't wish to live with it anymore. With the idea in mind that the person can't bare the situation further. THough thats all I can really see a person who wants to commit suicide feel.
     
  8. loO4la

    loO4la Well-Known Member

    158
    41
    0
    Wow, some of you guys are so judgemental!
    I think unless you guys have been in the EXACT situation as the person who has committed suicide and were able to move on with life, then you'd have the right to call them "cowards". Otherwise you are really in no position to judge them.

    EDIT: Actually even then you still wouldn't have the right to call them "cowards". Not everyone was raised to be "strong" and "brave" like you guys.
     
  9. Tao_lung

    Tao_lung Well-Known Member

    107
    41
    0
    What about a person who wanted to commit suicide but realize how cowardly it was and tried facing his problems and was able to deal with it. Cause Im saying I was a coward.
     
  10. loO4la

    loO4la Well-Known Member

    158
    41
    0
    Then good for you. But like I said not everyone is raised to be strong and brave. People go through different experiences and develop different approaches to certain situations in life. When you are depressed, your mind is not clear. Since you said that you were once like this, you should know this better than anybody else. Sometimes depression can take over your mind and make you do crazy stuff. Stuff you never thought you'd do when you weren't depressed.
     
  11. Tao_lung

    Tao_lung Well-Known Member

    107
    41
    0
    Feelings can drive a person to do crazy things, yes. Though your right, I was out of line and was basicly saying all that above cause seeing a life disappear is kind of heart breaking. It makes me angry that people would end there chapter in life like that. Anger clouded my judgement, Depression clouded my solution, happyness clouded the problems, Feelings cloud one another.
     
  12. kdotc

    kdotc 안녕하세요빅뱅K-Dragon입니다

    ^ thast y we have social workers to help them
     
  13. don

    don ello

    i agree with you.... everyone is different and it's a choice that a person makes and were all lucky here to not even have any problems that would make us want to suicide......it's easy to say that suiciding is stupid and why would pll do that and stuff but usually if a person suicides it means that that person cannot find comfort and feel that he/she has no where else to go and just don't wanna live anymore so i think everyone should somehow try and think about how it would feel.....
     
  14. aussiekid

    aussiekid Well-Known Member

    174
    41
    0
    lately i have been feeling hopeless.. too tired to continue wid anythin i'm doing.. my life.. i thot of suiciding.. but i'm tooo stupid to know how to do it the fastest and least painful way..
    my fren n i kept prayin.. i told myself to have faith in myself and God.. but it's like so many unfortunate events keep happening on me.. and i ain't strong enough to go on any longer..i'm tryin to b strong n tough.. but it seems to be breaking my mental and emotions down.. my family isn't wid me here.. and i cant tell them all this.. it'll only worry them more when there's enough pressure at home adi.. have faith ..
     
  15. don

    don ello

    thats a pretty tough situaton.....hope it all turns out the good way
     
  16. minjinseng

    minjinseng Member

    6
    26
    0
    I don't know where or who says it's not a sin anymore, that's the first time I've heard it in the Christian faith that it isn't. Your reason does not make much sense since there are a lot of things you can do because you weren't thinking right. Such as killing someone out of your anger, but they were your family.. does that justify that murder was not a sin because you weren't in the right state of mind?


    suicide is a sin but because it is, it doesn't mean that beacuse it is a part of my "religion" to look down on people who do it or who have done it or have thought about doing it.

    I think it is quite sad hearing that people have nothing else to live for in this world so they would rather end it. I heard recently from a friend that someone back at home had committed suicide beacuse she felt that no one cared and she didn't feel loved , and she was in high school. However, this girl was loved by so many people and it really hurt to send her away.

    To be honest, there were a couple of times that I didn't want to be where I was or in the situation that I was in, beacuse it was unbearing.

    I don't know, it's a hard topic. But for certain, regardless in whatever "religion" you are in, there are people who are suicidal.
     
  17. i don't have a religion... so it's ok if i kill myself??
     
  18. lol i was in a public bathroom today in the stalls it said... Judaism, Christianity... and below that said uff religion...
     
  19. mint_T

    mint_T Well-Known Member

    372
    53
    0
    It's a permenant solution to a temporary problem.
     
  20. aishiteru4

    aishiteru4 Well-Known Member

    1,306
    86
    0
    i dont have a religion... does that mean it doesnt really matter if i attempted a suicide?