TAIYOU NO UTA - Erika vs YUI?

erika in 1 liter of tears shed me my 1 liter of tears as well...

 

both of them are good...but i like erika better..lol...but i luv YUI's songs also...so..i cant really pick one

 

well, i only watched the one with erika.
but yui is extremely talented in singing,
and i agree with xhikarux

 

yui is great

 

Yui fits the role due to the nature of the cast.

 

I enjoyed both the drama and the movie. YUI's version for the music and Erika's version for the acting......not surprising since that's what they do. YUI's version is more appealing since her character is similar to the way she is in real life. I also think the YUI and Takashi pairing is much more cute.

 

I finally watch the drama and movie... story wise Drama was better than movie.. I felt for the characters more... singing wise well of course Yui would sound better

 

Yui! Defintitly! I have watch both film and Jdorama but I prefer YUI!

 

I didn't watch the series but watched the movie.I liked erika in '1 litre of tears' but still i like YUI's music

 

i like YUI as a singer. havent seen the film, currently following the series and on episode 3 but i can feel its going to be good drama. episode 3 is so sweet ~ i liked Erika in 1 litres of tears too and i think shes doing a pretty good job in the series too ~

 

Hm.. I think Erika was better, she is a really good actress and I loved her in 1 litre of tears. But I liked the drama better anyway.
The songs in the drama were good, though I also have to say that I don't really like her singing and that Yui is just a better singer.

 

just finished watching Taiyo no Uta drama ~ good drama, so sad......... ~ now i'll try and find the film version of this drama with YUI in it ~

 

^i watched the movie,it wasn't that great but i can't really tell because i haven't watched the drama.I don't think i will watch it either

 

where did you watch the film?? English subtitles?? ~

 

^i got the movie from a friend and yeah,it was subbed in English...
I will ask my friend where he downloaded it

 

Please, that would be great ^^

 

i prefer erika more
although yui did a fantastic job.

 

YUI is much better.

 

i think yui , her vocal is better

 

i think that they were both great, altho i thought Erika was really pretty for a sick person... not saying tha tsick ppl should be ugly or anything, just thought that after all that time she would have had some damage done right? altho i don't say the same for YUI (it never crossed my mind for the movie like it did for the drama).... i actually liked both songs, whether it was YUI's (i am a big fan) i thought Erika did well on the song for the drama... there was more story/ events in the drama, obviously due to the time. But i thought the movie was really good as well, i'd like to see YUI is something else but her music is obviously still amazing ^^