Tavia or Charmaine?

Discussion in 'Beyond The Realm Of Conscience - 宮心計' started by blue_penguin7, Dec 24, 2009.

  1. blue_penguin7

    blue_penguin7 Active Member

    37
    31
    0
    Overall, who do you think is the better actress, Tavia or Charmaine?
     
  2. worgorgec

    worgorgec Well-Known Member

    60
    234
    0
    Definetly Charmaine I mean Tavia has improved so much and I don't doubt that she is a good actress but i just find when Charmaine crys its more natural compared with Tavia and somehow when Charmaine is happy she seems genuniely happy while Tavia lacks a bit of naturalness
     
  3. sewerside

    sewerside Member

    6
    26
    0
    hmm for me.. i felt charmaine has alot of fake-good-ppl look on her face. nevertheless she is no doubt a good actress, it's just that the level naiveness of a good human is too much and this kinda good human are rarely exist
     
  4. justice88

    justice88 Member

    15
    26
    0
    charmaine
     
  5. silentjess

    silentjess Well-Known Member

    264
    53
    0
    both acted well in their roles. can't choose lei.
    charmaine has angel face so this role was like, so easy as her face reads 'angel'
    while tavia, if she was being the good one, it would be tougher to convince the audience.

    the challenge would be their roles reversed.
     
  6. tallgirl888

    tallgirl888 Well-Known Member

    235
    41
    0
    Background wise Tavia is a trained actor and Charmaine is from the HK Beauty Pageant...It is easier to play a good person than a bad person...
     
  7. charmaine
     
  8. Probably Charmaine... Even tho her characters attitude to 'life' is kinda annoyin ><"
    But I dun think Tavia's character was as believeable...
    Like I duno she still seemed too 'soft'?
     
  9. JellyBeanz

    JellyBeanz Well-Known Member

    55
    31
    0
    In this sereis, i think Tavia. She was great and i thought she oozed the word 'evil'.

    Charmaine was good too, however there was nothing that made me go 'wow'.
     
  10. I think it is Charmaine. But Tavia has improved a lot. Acting a bad person is not that easy, at least that is what i think.
     
  11. xiaoling

    xiaoling Member

    18
    26
    0
    love charmaine
     
  12. tkt138

    tkt138 Active Member

    36
    31
    0
    Definitely Charmaine. Tavia is improving a lot but she still not as good as Charmaine.
     
  13. yashi09

    yashi09 Active Member

    35
    31
    0
    i like tavia
     
  14. akuchy

    akuchy Member

    10
    26
    0
    Like Tavia more.
     
  15. codon

    codon Well-Known Member

    100
    41
    0
  16. lauchunwah

    lauchunwah Member

    5
    26
    0
    beyond realm of conscience

    charmaine but Tavia is good to..............
     
  17. xboys

    xboys Member

    14
    26
    0
    Both are good actress... But Tavia has improve alot in this drama...
     
  18. fun33533

    fun33533 Member

    5
    26
    0
  19. crazy_banana

    crazy_banana New Member

    1
    26
    0
    go charmaine!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
     
  20. fchbbs90

    fchbbs90 Member

    14
    26
    0
    charmaine's better, but tavia is improving